Key Takeaways
Dark circles aren’t one condition: A 2021 systematic review sorts them into pigmentary, structural, vascular, and mixed causes, and what helps depends on which one you have.
Genetics plays a large part: Cleveland Clinic notes dark circles may run in families and are more common in darker skin tones.
Home habits can make them less visible: Sleep, a cold compress, an extra pillow, and daily sunscreen are the steps Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinic both recommend.
Eye creams have modest evidence: The same 2021 review found few high-quality studies, so a cream can soften the look of dark circles but rarely clears them.
Darkness or swelling under one eye that keeps getting worse is a reason to see a doctor rather than try another product.
Why Dark Circles Are So Hard to Shift
Most people try one fix for dark circles and conclude nothing works. Often the fix was aimed at the wrong cause. Visible darkness under the eyes can be extra pigment in the skin, blood vessels showing through thin skin, a shadow cast by a hollow, or fluid that makes the lower lid puff and darken. Many people have more than one of these at once.
A 2021 systematic review in Dermatologic Surgery groups these into four types, “pigmentary, structural, vascular, and mixed,” and that grouping is the most useful way to work out what may help. This guide walks through how to recognize each type, what you can do at home, which ingredients have any evidence behind them, and what a dermatologist can add.
What Causes Dark Circles Under the Eyes?
Mayo Clinic’s list of causes covers genetics, eczema and contact dermatitis, fatigue, rubbing or scratching the eyes, skin changes with age, melasma and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, and sun exposure. It also notes that some dark circles “may be shadows cast by puffy eyelids or hollows under the eyes that develop with aging.”
Dermatologist Rebecca Marcus, MD, FAAD, summed up the two most common routes for mindbodygreen: “This can either be due to hyperpigmentation of the skin, or thin skin that allows blood vessels” to show through. In the same piece, dermatologist Brian Hibler, MD, added a third: “There are many causes for discoloration under the eyes, and one of them is hollowing or loss of volume.”
Allergies belong on the list too. Cleveland Clinic describes allergic shiners as “dark, discolored circles under your eyes that may look like black eyes,” brought on by nasal congestion from hay fever, pollen, pet dander, dust mites, or mold.
How to Tell Which Type You Have
These are rough guides you can check in a mirror in daylight. A dermatologist can confirm the type, and mixed cases are common.
Pigment: brown or grey-brown darkness from extra melanin. Mayo Clinic notes that melasma and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation are “more common in people with brown or Black skin.”
Visible blood vessels: a bluish or purplish cast. Like most dark circles, it tends to look more obvious when you’re tired. Dermatologist Joshua Zeichner, MD, told InStyle: “Because the skin in this area is thin, you can easily see blood vessels under the skin.”
Hollows and shadows: The darkness is a shadow, so it shifts with the light. It looks worst under overhead light and fades when light hits the under-eye straight on. Cleveland Clinic notes that hollows called tear troughs may develop with age and cast shadows.
Puffiness: darkness that sits under a swollen lower lid and is often worse in the morning or after a salty meal, when fluid collects in the area.
What Helps at Home
Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinic recommend the same short list. None of these erases dark circles, and several work best on the puffy and vascular types.
A cold compress: Mayo Clinic suggests “holding a cold, wet cloth against the area to help shrink the blood vessels,” or a cold teaspoon or a bag of frozen peas wrapped in a cloth.
Sleep, and an extra pillow: Mayo Clinic says short nights alone don’t usually cause dark circles but make existing ones more obvious. Sleeping with your head raised helps keep fluid from pooling in the lower lids.
Daily sunscreen and sunglasses: Sun exposure darkens pigment-type circles, so a broad-spectrum sunscreen around the eyes every day and sunglasses outdoors are especially important for that type.
Hands off: Cleveland Clinic lists rubbing and scratching as a cause, because they can make the area swell and break blood vessels.
Treat the trigger: If allergies or eczema are driving the darkness, getting them under control often does more than any eye product. Cleveland Clinic lists antihistamines, steroid or antihistamine nasal sprays, saline rinses, and avoiding the allergen for allergic shiners.
Concealer: The fastest way to even out the look of dark circles is still a concealer or color corrector, which Cleveland Clinic lists alongside the other home options.
Do Eye Creams Work on Dark Circles?
Some help a little, and the research is thinner than the shelf suggests. The 2021 Dermatologic Surgery review looked across treatments for periorbital hyperpigmentation and warned of “the scarcity of high-quality evidence.” Mayo Clinic also points out that nonprescription eye patches made with Kojic Acid, caffeine, or Vitamin K aren’t regulated by the FDA.
What that means in practice is matching the ingredient to the type:
Ingredients Worth Looking For, by Type
For pigment: Vitamin C, Niacinamide, and Retinoids are among the most common topical ingredients used for facial hyperpigmentation. In a 2022 open-label study in the Journal of Drugs in Dermatology, 16 people who used a Retinoid and AHA eye cream nightly for 12 weeks saw visible under-eye darkness improve by 41%. The study had no placebo group, so treat it as a promising signal rather than proof.
For visible blood vessels and thin skin: Retinoids and Peptides support collagen, and thicker-looking skin shows less of what sits underneath, so they’re a reasonable fit. High-quality trials on dark circles specifically are scarce.
For puffiness: Caffeine is a common ingredient in eye gels, and the cold itself helps too: chilling tightens blood vessels and reduces swelling.
For dryness that makes the area look dull: Hyaluronic Acid, Glycerin, and Ceramides keep skin hydrated, which helps it look smoother and can soften shadowing slightly.
What a Dermatologist Can Add
When home steps and creams aren’t enough, Mayo Clinic says a dermatologist may suggest prescription creams, laser therapy, chemical peels, or surgery to reduce puffy lids. In a 2025 meta-analysis reported by Dermatology Times, covering 33 studies and 1,320 patients, lasers had the largest share of patients with good-to-excellent improvement (82%), followed by combination treatments (75%).
The right procedure depends on the type, which is one more reason to get the type confirmed before spending on any treatment.
When Dark Circles Need a Doctor
Mayo Clinic advises talking to a healthcare professional “if you notice changes under just one eye that get worse over time.” Cleveland Clinic adds that dark circles that persist, or come with excessive swelling, are worth a visit, since an underlying condition may need treatment. If they last longer than a few weeks or tend to appear at certain times of year, an allergist may be able to help find the trigger.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you get rid of dark circles permanently?
Usually not with creams or home steps alone, because the most common causes, genetics, skin thickness, and the shape of the area under the eye, don’t go away. Those steps can make dark circles look softer, and in-office procedures can do more for some types.
Are dark circles caused by lack of sleep?
Not on their own, according to Mayo Clinic, though short nights make existing dark circles more obvious. Cleveland Clinic notes that poor sleep can make the skin under your eyes appear pale.
Are dark circles genetic?
Often, yes. Cleveland Clinic says they may run in families. Dermatologist Andrea Suarez, MD, FAAD, told mindbodygreen that “Genetics certainly can play a role, with some people more prone to either hyperpigmentation or under-eye shadowing.”
Can allergies cause dark circles?
Yes. Cleveland Clinic calls them allergic shiners, and they come from nasal congestion. Managing the allergy, with antihistamines, nasal sprays, or avoiding the trigger, is usually the most effective step.
What is the best eye cream for dark circles?
The one whose ingredients match your type: pigment-focused ingredients for brown darkness, ingredients for the look of firmness for bluish darkness, and caffeine or a cooling gel for puffiness. Our comparison of eye creams for sensitive skin covers gentler options if the area reacts easily.
When should I worry about dark circles?
When darkness or swelling affects one eye, gets worse over time, or doesn’t settle. Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinic both say to see a healthcare provider in those cases.
Sources
Journal of Drugs in Dermatology, 2022, open-label study of a Retinoid and AHA eye cream
Dermatology Times, Analyzing Current Procedures for Periorbital Hyperpigmentation, 2025
Illuminating the Shadows: An Insight into Periorbital Hyperpigmentation, Pigment International, 2024
Cleveland Clinic, Puffy Eyes: What Causes Them and What To Do About It


